Best First Basemen

Top First Basemen by true rating in MLB The Show 25

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#76
Justin Morneau, 98 Signature - MLB the Show 25
99.42 TR
Justin Morneau
Not Sellable
#77
Lance Berkman, 96 Prime - MLB the Show 25
99.33 TR
Lance Berkman
Not Sellable
#78
Isaac Paredes, 96 2025 All-Star - MLB the Show 25
99.16 TR
Isaac Paredes
Not Sellable
#79
Cool Papa Bell, 99 Jin Kim - MLB the Show 25
99.07 TR
Cool Papa Bell
Stubs 29,997
Stubs 9,805
#80
Ryan O'Hearn, 98 New Threads - MLB the Show 25
98.75 TR
Ryan O'Hearn
Stubs 5,614
Stubs 5,000
#81
C.J. Kayfus, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
98.53 TR
C.J. Kayfus
Stubs 8,489
Stubs 5,000
#82
Tony Clark, 98 Signature - MLB the Show 25
98.5 TR
Tony Clark
Stubs 5,999
Stubs 5,000
#83
Vladimir Guerrero Jr., 97 2025 All-Star - MLB the Show 25
98.35 TR
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Stubs 83,785
Stubs 50,134
#84
Vladimir Guerrero Jr., 95 Pipeline Past - MLB the Show 25
98.17 TR
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Stubs 56,999
Stubs 40,000
#85
Frank Thomas, 97 Contributor - MLB the Show 25
97.87 TR
Frank Thomas
Stubs 51,499
Stubs 44,001
#86
Frank Thomas, 97 Ranked 1000 - MLB the Show 25
97.87 TR
Frank Thomas
Not Sellable
#87
Ethan Conrad, 97 2025 Draft - MLB the Show 25
97.82 TR
Ethan Conrad
Not Sellable
#88
Josh Naylor, 98 New Threads - MLB the Show 25
97.67 TR
Josh Naylor
Not Sellable
#89
DJ LeMahieu, 98 Signature - MLB the Show 25
97.48 TR
DJ LeMahieu
Not Sellable
#90
Emmanuel Rivera, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
97.28 TR
Emmanuel Rivera
Stubs 6,839
Stubs 5,000
#91
Cam Devanney, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
97.03 TR
Cam Devanney
Stubs 5,998
Stubs 5,000
#92
Alec Burleson, 94 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
96.86 TR
Alec Burleson
Not Sellable
#93
Sal Stewart, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
96.84 TR
Sal Stewart
Not Sellable
#94
Nick Kurtz, 98 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
96.83 TR
Nick Kurtz
Stubs 7,444
Stubs 5,000
#95
Samuel Basallo, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
96.61 TR
Samuel Basallo
Not Sellable
#96
Andrew Vaughn, 97 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
96.35 TR
Andrew Vaughn
Not Sellable
#97
Hunter Goodman, 96 2025 All-Star - MLB the Show 25
96.31 TR
Hunter Goodman
Not Sellable
#98
Pete Alonso, 96 2025 All-Star - MLB the Show 25
96.28 TR
Pete Alonso
Not Sellable
#99
Jared Triolo, 98 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
96.25 TR
Jared Triolo
Not Sellable
#100
Liover Peguero, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 25
96.22 TR
Liover Peguero
Not Sellable

Best First Basemen in MLB The Show 25 - Insights

Moonshot Hank Aaron holds the top spot among the best First Basemen with an impressive 112.26 True Rating.

Right behind Hank Aaron are Neon Lou Gehrig and Home Run Derby X Daniel Murphy, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB First Basemen average a 109.91 True Rating.

Home Run Derby X Daniel Murphy the most recent addition to the top 10, released 1 month ago, and also is a top free option, ranked #3. This card can be acquired from the Home Run Derby X Program.

Neon Lou Gehrig is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 11 active quirks.

Hall of Fame Honus Wagner currently the most expensive player available on the market among the top 5, costing around 164,995 stubs.