Egg Hunt Guide & FAQ - MLB The Show 25

Welcome to the Egg Hunt!

The Egg Hunt program challenges you to complete hidden objectives (Mystery Missions) and find collectible Egg Vouchers scattered across Diamond Dynasty modes.

Completing Mystery Missions earns Stars towards the program, while collecting 5 of the 7 available Egg Vouchers grants a significant 50-Star bonus. Use this guide to crack the clues and find everything you need!

Mystery Missions (5 Stars Each)

Each mystery mission is tied to a pun or hidden clue. Complete the requirement in the specified mode to earn 5 Stars towards the Egg Hunt program.

Trivia Night

Requirement:Get a Quality Start (Pitch at least 6 innings while giving up 3 or fewer earned runs) with Vida Blue.
Mode: Play vs CPU(any Diamond Dynasty Mode)

(See FAQ below on how to get Vida Blue)

Wait A Second

Requirement: Win a game with the Silver Randy Johnson card.
Mode: Any Diamond Dynasty Mode

(See FAQ below on how to get Silver Randy Johnson)

Woah There, Slow Down

Requirement: Tally a double with a player who has 15 speed or lower.
Mode: Play vs CPU

Swordfish

Requirement: Strike out with Mike Trout at the plate (any version).
Mode: Any Diamond Dynasty Mode

(See FAQ below on how to get a Mike Trout card)

Tax Season

Requirement: Record 2 Holds with relief pitchers. (A hold is recorded when a pitcher records at least one out while maintaining a lead.)
Mode: Mini Seasons

Let's Roll

Requirement: Tally 6 Hits in a single game.
Mode: Diamond Quest

Big Conquest Mystery

Requirement: Record a Save with a Left-Handed Pitcher.
Mode: Conquest

Small Ball

Requirement: Record a Sacrifice play (Sac Fly or Sac Bunt).
Mode: Mini Seasons

Collectible Egg Vouchers (Collect 5 for 50 Stars)

Find 7 unique Egg Vouchers hidden throughout Diamond Dynasty modes. You only need to collect 5 different Vouchers to earn the massive 50-Star collection reward!

Purple Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Complete all of the Moments listed within the Egg Hunt Program menu.

Green Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Enter the Egg Hunt Diamond Quest map and successfully win the game located at the LEFTMOST Stadium Challenge space.

Blue Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Enter the Egg Hunt Diamond Quest map and successfully win the game located at the RIGHTMOST Stadium Challenge space.

Red Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Play the "Bunny Ears" Conquest map. Capture both the Kansas City Royals and Colorado Rockies Strongholds. Map completion is not required.

Yellow Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Also in the "Bunny Ears" Conquest map, capture both the Miami Marlins and Tampa Bay Rays Strongholds. Map completion is not required.

Pink Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Accumulate 25 strikeouts with your pitchers across any online modes (Ranked, BR, Events, Co-op). Cumulative total.

Orange Egg Voucher

How to Earn: Have your batters get on base 25 times (Hit, Walk, HBP) across any online modes (Ranked, BR, Events, Co-op). Cumulative total.

Tip: You can skip any two eggs and still get the full 50 stars from the collection reward. Focus on the modes you enjoy most!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I get the Silver Randy Johnson card?

The easiest way to get a Randy Johnson card for the Wait A Second mission is the Silver Randy Johnson, available as the first reward in the Seattle Mariners Team Affinity program (complete the "Start Here" Moment).

How do I get the Vida Blue card?

The Trivia Night mission requires a Quality Start with any Vida Blue card. Both versions can be obtained from the Common Courtesy Program (found under Other Programs):

  • You can acquire the 86 OVR All-Star Vida Blue by completing the Common Courtesy collection after you get the 60 Overall Vida Blue
  • Either card will work to complete the "Trivia Night" mystery mission requirement.

How do I get a Mike Trout card?

The easiest way to get a Mike Trout card for the Swordfish mission is the 78 OVR Mike Trout, available as the first reward in the Los Angeles Angels Team Affinity program (complete the "Start Here" Moment). His Live Series card will also work.

What's the main reward for the Egg Hunt?

The final reward on the Egg Hunt Program path (at 100 Stars) is 89 OVR Egg Hunt Series Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Additionally, there is a separate Egg Hunt Collection (under Collections > Legends & Flashbacks). Collecting Egg Hunt Series players (from the program, packs, Conquest, etc.) unlocks:

Do I need to do the missions or find eggs in a specific order?

No, you can complete Mystery Missions and find Egg Vouchers in any order you like. However, completing the Moments first is often recommended as it unlocks the Purple Egg Voucher needed for the collection.

How do I track my progress?

You can track your progress (Stars earned, Missions completed, Eggs collected) within the Egg Hunt Program menu, usually found under Programs > Other Programs in Diamond Dynasty. Egg Vouchers will appear in your Collections once earned.

Does the Egg Hunt Program expire?

Typically, main programs like this do not fully expire, meaning you can usually complete them later. However, related content like specific packs in the shop or associated Events might be time-limited.

Are the Egg Vouchers sellable?

No, the Egg Vouchers are collection items used to gain program stars. They are No Sell and cannot be bought or sold on the Community Market.