MLB The Show Rankings

Top players by true rating for each position

What is True Rating?
  • Rankings include quirk values and secondary positions by default.
  • Quirk values estimate how quirks impact a player's overall ability.
Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players

Designated Hitter Rankings

Lou Gehrig, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
123.49 TR
Hank Aaron, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
121.21 TR
Stan Musial, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
121.01 TR

Catcher Rankings

Ivan Rodriguez, 99 Awards - MLB the Show undefined
115.75 TR
William Contreras, 99 2024 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
112.24 TR
Adley Rutschman, 99 Awards - MLB the Show undefined
112.07 TR

First Base Rankings

Lou Gehrig, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
122.61 TR
Hank Aaron, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
120.72 TR
Stan Musial, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
120.4 TR

Second Base Rankings

Mookie Betts, 99 2024 Postseason - MLB the Show undefined
115.42 TR
Jackie Robinson, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
114.02 TR
Mookie Betts, 99 Season Awards - MLB the Show undefined
112.87 TR

Third Base Rankings

Freddie Freeman, 99 2024 Postseason - MLB the Show undefined
115.09 TR
Ernie Banks, 99 Action Figure - MLB the Show undefined
114.48 TR
Eddie Mathews, 99 Action Figure - MLB the Show undefined
114.01 TR

Shortstop Rankings

Mookie Betts, 99 2024 Postseason - MLB the Show undefined
114.81 TR
Ernie Banks, 99 Action Figure - MLB the Show undefined
113.53 TR
Jackie Robinson, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
113.01 TR

Left Field Rankings

Ronald Acuna Jr., 99 Awards - MLB the Show undefined
118.13 TR
Hank Aaron, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
117.06 TR
Aaron Judge, 99 2024 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
115.84 TR

Center Field Rankings

Ronald Acuna Jr., 99 Awards - MLB the Show undefined
117.33 TR
Hank Aaron, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
116.03 TR
Aaron Judge, 99 2024 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
115 TR

Right Field Rankings

Ronald Acuna Jr., 99 Awards - MLB the Show undefined
118.7 TR
Hank Aaron, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
117.84 TR
Aaron Judge, 99 2024 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
116.03 TR

Starting Pitcher Rankings

Jacob deGrom, 99 Awards - MLB the Show undefined
112.97 TR
Randy Johnson, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
112.85 TR
Pedro Martinez, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show undefined
112.14 TR

Relief Pitcher Rankings

Josh Staumont, 99 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
106.62 TR
Rob Dibble, 99 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
105.88 TR
Joe Kelly, 99 Captain - MLB the Show undefined
104.08 TR

Closing Pitcher Rankings

Craig Kimbrel, 99 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
106.35 TR
Justin Martinez, 99 2024 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
106.16 TR
Kenley Jansen, 99 Finest - MLB the Show undefined
105.21 TR