Best First Basemen

Top First Basemen by true rating in MLB The Show 25

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#1
Vladimir Guerrero Jr., 99 2025 Postseason - MLB the Show 25
114.79 TR
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Not Sellable
#2
Hank Aaron, 99 Moonshot - MLB the Show 25
112.48 TR
Hank Aaron
Not Sellable
#3
Lou Gehrig, 99 Neon - MLB the Show 25
111.67 TR
Lou Gehrig
Not Sellable
#4
Daniel Murphy, 99 Home Run Derby X - MLB the Show 25
111.2 TR
Daniel Murphy
Not Sellable
#5
Stan Musial, 99 Spooky - MLB the Show 25
110.88 TR
Stan Musial
Not Sellable
#6
Honus Wagner, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
110.71 TR
Honus Wagner
Stubs 104,887
Stubs 71,000
#7
Hank Greenberg, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
110.4 TR
Hank Greenberg
Not Sellable
#8
Vladimir Guerrero Jr., 99 2025 Postseason - MLB the Show 25
110.29 TR
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Not Sellable
#9
Buck Leonard, 99 The Negro Leagues - MLB the Show 25
109.65 TR
Buck Leonard
Not Sellable
#10
Frank Thomas, 99 Cornerstone - MLB the Show 25
109.3 TR
Frank Thomas
Not Sellable
#11
Cody Bellinger, 99 2025 Finest - MLB the Show 25
109.12 TR
Cody Bellinger
Not Sellable
#12
Eddie Mathews, 99 Cornerstone - MLB the Show 25
109.12 TR
Eddie Mathews
Not Sellable
#13
Ben Zobrist, 99 Home Run Derby X - MLB the Show 25
109.07 TR
Ben Zobrist
Not Sellable
#14
George Brett, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
108.89 TR
George Brett
Stubs 33,997
Stubs 25,000
#15
Ryan Zimmerman, 99 Home Run Derby X - MLB the Show 25
108.83 TR
Ryan Zimmerman
Stubs 38,998
Stubs 29,001
#16
Rafael Palmeiro, 99 Neon - MLB the Show 25
108.75 TR
Rafael Palmeiro
Not Sellable
#17
Harmon Killebrew, 99 Spooky - MLB the Show 25
108.59 TR
Harmon Killebrew
Not Sellable
#18
Carlos Santana, 99 Milestone - MLB the Show 25
108.56 TR
Carlos Santana
Not Sellable
#19
Todd Helton, 99 Prime - MLB the Show 25
108.27 TR
Todd Helton
Not Sellable
#20
Mike Piazza, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
108.01 TR
Mike Piazza
Stubs 94,999
Stubs 78,500
#21
Lance Berkman, 99 Neon - MLB the Show 25
107.98 TR
Lance Berkman
Not Sellable
#22
Johnny Bench, 99 Cornerstone - MLB the Show 25
107.97 TR
Johnny Bench
Not Sellable
#23
Josh Naylor, 99 2025 Postseason - MLB the Show 25
107.86 TR
Josh Naylor
Not Sellable
#24
Monte Irvin, 99 The Negro Leagues - MLB the Show 25
107.78 TR
Monte Irvin
Not Sellable
#25
Adrian Gonzalez, 99 Home Run Derby X - MLB the Show 25
107.61 TR
Adrian Gonzalez
Stubs 39,996
Stubs 28,507

Best First Basemen in MLB The Show 25 - Insights

2025 Postseason Vladimir Guerrero Jr. holds the top spot among the best First Basemen with an impressive 114.79 True Rating, and also the most recent addition to the top 10, released 5 days ago.

Right behind Vladimir Guerrero Jr. are Moonshot Hank Aaron and Neon Lou Gehrig, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB First Basemen average a 111.14 True Rating.

Neon Lou Gehrig is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 11 active quirks.