Best Catchers
Top Catchers by true rating in MLB The Show 25
- Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
- Rankings with Secondary Position players
Best Catchers in MLB The Show 25 - Insights
2025 Home Run Derby Cal Raleigh holds the top spot among the best Catchers with an impressive 101.88 True Rating.
Right behind Cal Raleigh are Prime Mike Napoli and 2025 All-Star Will Smith, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB Catchers average a 97.56 True Rating.
2025 All-Star Alejandro Kirk is a top free option, ranked #4. This card can be acquired from the Team Affinity All-Star Game.
For budget-conscious players, additional options to consider within the top 10 (under 15,000 stubs) include 2025 All-Star Will Smith (14,994 stubs), Prime Jason Varitek (7,270 stubs), and Topps Now Patrick Bailey (7,295 stubs).
Prime Mike Napoli the most recent addition to the top 10, released 5 days ago, and also currently the most expensive player available on the market among the top 5, costing around 89,899 stubs; Additionally, this card is is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 7 active quirks.