Best Catchers

Top Catchers by true rating in MLB The Show 25

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#1
Cal Raleigh, 99 2025 Finest - MLB the Show 25
110.63 TR
Cal Raleigh
Not Sellable
#2
Gary Carter, 99 Finest - MLB the Show 25
109.98 TR
Gary Carter
Not Sellable
#3
Johnny Bench, 99 Cornerstone - MLB the Show 25
108.95 TR
Johnny Bench
Not Sellable
#4
Alejandro Kirk, 99 2025 Postseason - MLB the Show 25
108.38 TR
Alejandro Kirk
Not Sellable
#5
Gary Sanchez, 99 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
108.33 TR
Gary Sanchez
Not Sellable
#6
Will Smith, 99 2025 Postseason - MLB the Show 25
108 TR
Will Smith
Not Sellable
#7
Joe Mauer, 99 Moonshot - MLB the Show 25
107.84 TR
Joe Mauer
Not Sellable
#8
Ivan Rodriguez, 99 Moonshot - MLB the Show 25
107.24 TR
Ivan Rodriguez
Stubs 18,886
Stubs 6,116
#9
Biz Mackey, 99 Jin Kim - MLB the Show 25
106.43 TR
Biz Mackey
Stubs 143,800
Stubs 70,005
#10
William Contreras, 99 2025 Finest - MLB the Show 25
106.15 TR
William Contreras
Not Sellable
#11
Josh Gibson, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
106 TR
Josh Gibson
Stubs 33,000
Stubs 8,277
#12
Carlos Santana, 99 Milestone - MLB the Show 25
105.86 TR
Carlos Santana
Not Sellable
#13
Mike Piazza, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
105.83 TR
Mike Piazza
Stubs 22,298
Stubs 6,500
#14
Martín Dihigo, 99 The Negro Leagues - MLB the Show 25
105.34 TR
Martín Dihigo
Stubs 15,000
Stubs 5,000
#15
Patrick Bailey, 99 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
105.05 TR
Patrick Bailey
Stubs 18,998
Stubs 6,700
#16
Drake Baldwin, 99 2025 Finest - MLB the Show 25
104.71 TR
Drake Baldwin
Not Sellable
#17
Ted Simmons, 99 Hall of Fame - MLB the Show 25
104.05 TR
Ted Simmons
Stubs 9,999
Stubs 5,000
#18
Dillon Dingler, 99 2025 Finest - MLB the Show 25
103.88 TR
Dillon Dingler
Stubs 57,996
Stubs 35,251
#19
Iván Herrera, 99 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
103.88 TR
Iván Herrera
Stubs 17,697
Stubs 8,600
#20
Gabriel Moreno, 99 Spotlight - MLB the Show 25
103.87 TR
Gabriel Moreno
Not Sellable
#21
Carson Kelly, 99 2025 Postseason - MLB the Show 25
103.86 TR
Carson Kelly
Not Sellable
#22
Jorge Posada, 99 Signature - MLB the Show 25
103.57 TR
Jorge Posada
Not Sellable
#23
Jason Varitek, 99 Finest - MLB the Show 25
103.39 TR
Jason Varitek
Stubs 209,999
Stubs 157,003
#24
Adley Rutschman, 99 Neon - MLB the Show 25
103.05 TR
Adley Rutschman
Not Sellable
#25
J.T. Realmuto, 99 Milestone - MLB the Show 25
102.8 TR
J.T. Realmuto
Not Sellable

Best Catchers in MLB The Show 25 - Insights

2025 Finest Cal Raleigh holds the top spot among the best Catchers with an impressive 110.63 True Rating.

Right behind Cal Raleigh are Finest Gary Carter and Cornerstone Johnny Bench, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB Catchers average a 108.19 True Rating.

Finest Gary Carter the most recent addition to the top 10, released 2 weeks ago, and also is a top free option, ranked #2. This card can be acquired from the Finest Program.

Cornerstone Johnny Bench is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 9 active quirks.