Best First Basemen

Top First Basemen by true rating in MLB The Show 25

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#551
Jack Winkler, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.81 TR
Jack Winkler
Stubs 43
Stubs 5
#552
Jair Camargo, 64 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.8 TR
Jair Camargo
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#553
Lyonell James, 55 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.65 TR
Lyonell James
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#554
Mahki Backstrom, 55 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.49 TR
Mahki Backstrom
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#555
Mickey Gasper, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.33 TR
Mickey Gasper
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#556
Lyle Lin, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.16 TR
Lyle Lin
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#557
Andy Yerzy, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.14 TR
Andy Yerzy
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#558
Cristian Feliz, 55 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.06 TR
Cristian Feliz
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#559
Grae Kessinger, 58 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.95 TR
Grae Kessinger
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#560
Maxwell Costes, 54 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.93 TR
Maxwell Costes
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#561
Jeferson Morales, 62 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.92 TR
Jeferson Morales
Stubs 10
Stubs 5
#562
Luis Martinez, 53 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.51 TR
Luis Martinez
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#563
Tucker Barnhart, 58 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.49 TR
Tucker Barnhart
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#564
Luke Maile, 62 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.46 TR
Luke Maile
Stubs 12
Stubs 5
#565
Andres Sosa, 62 Live - MLB the Show 25
52.8 TR
Andres Sosa
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#566
Cristian Garcia, 54 Live - MLB the Show 25
52.08 TR
Cristian Garcia
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#567
Kenneth Betancourt, 58 Live - MLB the Show 25
51.93 TR
Kenneth Betancourt
Stubs 5
Stubs 5
#568
Peyton Holt, 54 Live - MLB the Show 25
51.04 TR
Peyton Holt
Stubs 15
Stubs 5
#569
Enzo Paulino, 48 Live - MLB the Show 25
49.66 TR
Enzo Paulino
Stubs 536
Stubs 5
#570
Tyler Herron, 55 Live - MLB the Show 25
49.4 TR
Tyler Herron
Stubs 27
Stubs 5

Best First Basemen in MLB The Show 25 - Insights

2025 Postseason Vladimir Guerrero Jr. holds the top spot among the best First Basemen with an impressive 114.79 True Rating, and also the most recent addition to the top 10, released 5 days ago.

Right behind Vladimir Guerrero Jr. are Moonshot Hank Aaron and Neon Lou Gehrig, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB First Basemen average a 111.14 True Rating.

Neon Lou Gehrig is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 11 active quirks.