Best Designated Hitters

Top Designated Hitters by true rating in MLB The Show 25

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#1876
Luca Tresh, 68 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.11 TR
Luca Tresh
Stubs 245
Stubs 25
#1877
Tim Anderson, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.03 TR
Tim Anderson
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#1878
Jacob Teter, 56 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.02 TR
Jacob Teter
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#1879
Matheu Nelson, 66 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.01 TR
Matheu Nelson
Stubs 29
Stubs 25
#1880
Jacob Hurtubise, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
54.01 TR
Jacob Hurtubise
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1881
Brett Phillips, 66 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.98 TR
Brett Phillips
Stubs 29
Stubs 25
#1882
Ryan Leitch, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.87 TR
Ryan Leitch
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1883
Martin Maldonado, 64 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.82 TR
Martin Maldonado
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1884
J.C. Correa, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.79 TR
J.C. Correa
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#1885
Michael Cantu, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.73 TR
Michael Cantu
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1886
Chadwick Tromp, 64 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.68 TR
Chadwick Tromp
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#1887
JoJo Blackmon, 62 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.64 TR
JoJo Blackmon
Stubs 9
Stubs 5
#1888
Nick Dalesandro, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.51 TR
Nick Dalesandro
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#1889
Nick Schnell, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.5 TR
Nick Schnell
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#1890
Cristian Feliz, 55 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.47 TR
Cristian Feliz
Stubs 9
Stubs 5
#1891
Luis Baez, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.42 TR
Luis Baez
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1892
Estiven Machado, 56 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.41 TR
Estiven Machado
Stubs 7
Stubs 5
#1893
Carmine Lane, 59 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.34 TR
Carmine Lane
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1894
Cristian Pache, 66 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.31 TR
Cristian Pache
Stubs 28
Stubs 25
#1895
Terrin Vavra, 62 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.3 TR
Terrin Vavra
Stubs 6
Stubs 5
#1896
Ben Ramirez, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.27 TR
Ben Ramirez
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#1897
Yoyner Fajardo, 61 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.26 TR
Yoyner Fajardo
Stubs 18
Stubs 5
#1898
Brody Moore, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.21 TR
Brody Moore
Stubs 8
Stubs 5
#1899
Jack Winkler, 63 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.13 TR
Jack Winkler
Stubs 23
Stubs 5
#1900
Nick Vogt, 60 Live - MLB the Show 25
53.04 TR
Nick Vogt
Stubs 8
Stubs 5

Best Designated Hitters in MLB The Show 25 - Insights

2025 Postseason Vladimir Guerrero Jr. holds the top spot among the best Designated Hitters with an impressive 112.98 True Rating.

Right behind Vladimir Guerrero Jr. are 2025 Finest Juan Soto and Moonshot Joe Morgan, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB Designated Hitters average a 111.72 True Rating.

2025 Finest Juan Soto is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 10 active quirks.

2025 Finest José Ramírez currently the most expensive player available on the market among the top 5, costing around 925,000 stubs.

2025 Finest Fernando Tatis Jr. the most recent addition to the top 10, released 3 days ago.