Best Shortstops

Top Shortstops by true rating in MLB The Show 24

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#201
Spencer Steer, 93 Season Awards - MLB the Show 24
88.86 TR
Spencer Steer
Not Sellable
#202
Jerry Hairston Jr., 91 Hyper - MLB the Show 24
88.85 TR
Jerry Hairston Jr.
Stubs 5,000
Stubs 1,000
#203
Addison Barger, 93 Topps Now - MLB the Show 24
88.82 TR
Addison Barger
Not Sellable
#204
Carlos Correa, 92 Season Awards - MLB the Show 24
88.79 TR
Carlos Correa
Stubs -
Stubs -
#205
Matt McLain, 91 Hyper - MLB the Show 24
88.79 TR
Matt McLain
Stubs 65
Stubs 25
#206
Mike Schmidt, 94 Standout - MLB the Show 24
88.75 TR
Mike Schmidt
Not Sellable
#207
Javier Báez, 91 All-Star - MLB the Show 24
88.62 TR
Javier Báez
Stubs -
Stubs -
#208
Tommy Edman, 91 Incognito - MLB the Show 24
88.59 TR
Tommy Edman
Stubs -
Stubs -
#209
Lourdes Gurriel Jr., 92 Season Awards - MLB the Show 24
88.58 TR
Lourdes Gurriel Jr.
Stubs -
Stubs -
#210
Aledmys Diaz, 91 All-Star Game - MLB the Show 24
88.53 TR
Aledmys Diaz
Stubs 25
Stubs 25
#211
José Ramírez, 92 Live - MLB the Show 24
88.48 TR
José Ramírez
Stubs -
Stubs -
#212
Jake Cronenworth, 92 Season Awards - MLB the Show 24
88.26 TR
Jake Cronenworth
Stubs 78,883
Stubs 25,500
#213
Brady House, 93 Futures Skills Showcase - MLB the Show 24
88.1 TR
Brady House
Not Sellable
#214
Ketel Marte, 92 Live - MLB the Show 24
87.95 TR
Ketel Marte
Stubs -
Stubs -
#215
Barry Larkin, 89 Breakout - MLB the Show 24
87.87 TR
Barry Larkin
Stubs -
Stubs -
#216
Royce Lewis, 89 Postseason - MLB the Show 24
87.84 TR
Royce Lewis
Not Sellable
#217
Oswaldo Cabrera, 92 Season Awards - MLB the Show 24
87.74 TR
Oswaldo Cabrera
Stubs -
Stubs -
#218
Sebastian Walcott, 91 Pipeline - MLB the Show 24
87.57 TR
Sebastian Walcott
Stubs -
Stubs -
#219
José Iglesias, 91 Topps Now - MLB the Show 24
87.49 TR
José Iglesias
Stubs -
Stubs -
#220
Tyler Black, 95 Topps Now - MLB the Show 24
87.42 TR
Tyler Black
Not Sellable
#221
Austin Martin, 91 Topps Now - MLB the Show 24
87.28 TR
Austin Martin
Stubs -
Stubs -
#222
Adrian Beltre, 90 Hyper - MLB the Show 24
87.23 TR
Adrian Beltre
Stubs -
Stubs -
#223
Orelvis Martinez, 93 Pipeline - MLB the Show 24
87.21 TR
Orelvis Martinez
Not Sellable
#224
Joseph Ortiz, 91 Pipeline - MLB the Show 24
87.09 TR
Joseph Ortiz
Stubs -
Stubs -
#225
Fernando Tatis Jr., 89 Rookie - MLB the Show 24
86.92 TR
Fernando Tatis Jr.
Not Sellable

Best Shortstops in MLB The Show 24 - Insights

Topps Now Gunnar Henderson holds the top spot among the best Shortstops with an impressive 112.75 True Rating, and also the most recent addition to the top 10, released 1 year ago.

Right behind Gunnar Henderson are Topps Now Elly De La Cruz and 2024 Finest Bobby Witt Jr., forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB Shortstops average a 109.22 True Rating.

2024 Finest Bobby Witt Jr. is a top free option, ranked #3. This card can be acquired from the Season 4 XP Reward Path.

Hall of Fame Jackie Robinson is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 7 active quirks.