| Lineup | Username | Created |
|---|---|---|
| RIP 2024 New York Yankees | YRNtigerr | October 31, 2024 Thursday |
| RIP 2024 New York Mets | YRNtigerr | October 31, 2024 Thursday |
| Tigers Theme Team | savvyfuzzball68 | October 31, 2024 Thursday |
| Best Fielding Team | nojohns | October 30, 2024 Wednesday |
| Best Batting Team | nojohns | October 29, 2024 Tuesday |
| Dodgers Squad | nojohns | October 29, 2024 Tuesday |
| My Live Team | nojohns | October 28, 2024 Monday |
| Hall of Fame | jsein456 | October 27, 2024 Sunday |
| Core | sparkles_senpai | October 25, 2024 Friday |
| HAWK TUAH | cartersjsbetter | October 24, 2024 Thursday |
| La Patria 1 | kikitheboss2469 | October 22, 2024 Tuesday |
| God Squad For World Series | christopherharris | October 21, 2024 Monday |
| favorit season 1? | coopkev3 | October 16, 2024 Wednesday |
| season 2 | coopkev3 | October 16, 2024 Wednesday |
| season 3 best lineup #1 | coopkev3 | October 16, 2024 Wednesday |
| Legends MLB The Show 23 | armani128 | October 16, 2024 Wednesday |
| MLB The Show 23 Diamond Dynasty | armani128 | October 16, 2024 Wednesday |
| Hhfhdggh | domeasy | October 14, 2024 Monday |
| Yanks | fish1931 | October 14, 2024 Monday |
| 2024 Padres | YRNtigerr | October 13, 2024 Sunday |