Best First Basemen

Top First Basemen by true rating in MLB The Show 23

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#126
Luis Arraez, 98 Monthly Awards - MLB the Show 23
102.21 TR
Luis Arraez
Not Sellable
#127
Miguel Cabrera, 99 World Baseball Classic - MLB the Show 23
102.16 TR
Miguel Cabrera
Stubs -
Stubs -
#128
David Justice, 97 Great Race of '98 - MLB the Show 23
102.09 TR
David Justice
Stubs -
Stubs -
#129
Kerry Carpenter, 99 2023 Finest - MLB the Show 23
101.94 TR
Kerry Carpenter
Not Sellable
#130
J.T. Realmuto, 99 World Baseball Classic - MLB the Show 23
101.5 TR
J.T. Realmuto
Stubs -
Stubs -
#131
Raul Ibanez, 97 All-Star Game - MLB the Show 23
101.32 TR
Raul Ibanez
Not Sellable
#132
Jeff Bagwell, 99 Milestone - MLB the Show 23
101.31 TR
Jeff Bagwell
Stubs -
Stubs -
#133
Mr. Cub, 97 Incognito - MLB the Show 23
101.3 TR
Mr. Cub
Not Sellable
#134
Adam Duvall, 98 Monthly Awards - MLB the Show 23
101.29 TR
Adam Duvall
Not Sellable
#135
Luis Arraez, 97 Topps Now - MLB the Show 23
101.27 TR
Luis Arraez
Not Sellable
#136
Adam Wainwright, 99 Topps Now - MLB the Show 23
101.26 TR
Adam Wainwright
Not Sellable
#137
Wilmer Flores, 99 2023 Finest - MLB the Show 23
101.22 TR
Wilmer Flores
Not Sellable
#138
Ralph Kiner, 95 2nd Half Heroes - MLB the Show 23
101.09 TR
Ralph Kiner
Stubs -
Stubs -
#139
Willie Stargell, 97 Milestone - MLB the Show 23
101.05 TR
Willie Stargell
Stubs -
Stubs -
#140
Justin Turner, 99 2023 Finest - MLB the Show 23
100.99 TR
Justin Turner
Not Sellable
#141
Brandon Drury, 97 Monthly Awards - MLB the Show 23
100.62 TR
Brandon Drury
Not Sellable
#142
Jose Miranda, 97 Charisma - MLB the Show 23
100.58 TR
Jose Miranda
Not Sellable
#143
George Brett, 97 Snapshot - MLB the Show 23
100.58 TR
George Brett
Not Sellable
#144
Miguel Cabrera, 97 Home Run Derby - MLB the Show 23
100.52 TR
Miguel Cabrera
Not Sellable
#145
Billy Williams, 97 Kaiju - MLB the Show 23
100.47 TR
Billy Williams
Not Sellable
#146
Porterhouse, 97 Incognito - MLB the Show 23
100.39 TR
Porterhouse
Not Sellable
#147
Brent Rooker, 98 Monthly Awards - MLB the Show 23
100.33 TR
Brent Rooker
Not Sellable
#148
Gary Carter, 99 Awards - MLB the Show 23
100.32 TR
Gary Carter
Stubs -
Stubs -
#149
Mike Moustakas, 97 Home Run Derby - MLB the Show 23
100.27 TR
Mike Moustakas
Stubs 0
Stubs 1,112
#150
Rhys Hoskins, 97 Home Run Derby - MLB the Show 23
100.23 TR
Rhys Hoskins
Stubs -
Stubs -

Best First Basemen in MLB The Show 23 - Insights

2023 Finest Bryce Harper holds the top spot among the best First Basemen with an impressive 114.57 True Rating, and also is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 10 active quirks.

Right behind Bryce Harper are Milestone Babe Ruth and Topps Now Vladimir Guerrero Jr., forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB First Basemen average a 112.68 True Rating.

Milestone Babe Ruth is a top free option, ranked #2. This card can be acquired from the Set 1 Collection.

Topps Now Vladimir Guerrero Jr. the most recent addition to the top 10, released 2 years ago.