Best Catchers

Top Catchers by true rating in MLB The Show 23

On this page:

Quirks Secondaries
  • Rankings with Quirks ratings. (Estimates how quirks impact a player's overall ability.)
  • Rankings with Secondary Position players
What is True Rating?
BattingHand
#226
Tucker Barnhart, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.85 TR
Tucker Barnhart
Stubs -
Stubs -
#227
Riley Adams, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.54 TR
Riley Adams
Stubs -
Stubs -
#228
Ben Rortvedt, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.53 TR
Ben Rortvedt
Stubs -
Stubs -
#229
Yermin Mercedes, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.49 TR
Yermin Mercedes
Stubs -
Stubs -
#230
Miguel Amaya, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.38 TR
Miguel Amaya
Stubs -
Stubs -
#231
Austin Wynns, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.24 TR
Austin Wynns
Stubs -
Stubs -
#232
Kevin Plawecki, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
67.2 TR
Kevin Plawecki
Stubs -
Stubs -
#233
Hunter Goodman, 63 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.91 TR
Hunter Goodman
Stubs -
Stubs -
#234
David Fry, 71 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.85 TR
David Fry
Stubs -
Stubs -
#235
Tyler Malone, 64 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.84 TR
Tyler Malone
Stubs -
Stubs -
#236
Tyler Heineman, 67 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.72 TR
Tyler Heineman
Stubs -
Stubs -
#237
Michael Perez, 67 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.58 TR
Michael Perez
Stubs -
Stubs -
#238
Tyler Cropley, 67 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.58 TR
Tyler Cropley
Stubs -
Stubs -
#239
Tyler Soderstrom, 68 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.52 TR
Tyler Soderstrom
Stubs -
Stubs -
#240
Joey Bart, 66 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.46 TR
Joey Bart
Stubs -
Stubs -
#241
Cooper Hummel, 67 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.44 TR
Cooper Hummel
Stubs -
Stubs -
#242
Curt Casali, 67 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.36 TR
Curt Casali
Stubs -
Stubs -
#243
Mike Zunino, 66 Live - MLB the Show 23
66.04 TR
Mike Zunino
Stubs -
Stubs -
#244
Gavin Collins, 66 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.92 TR
Gavin Collins
Stubs -
Stubs -
#245
Ford Proctor, 65 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.59 TR
Ford Proctor
Stubs -
Stubs -
#246
Guillermo Quintana, 59 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.57 TR
Guillermo Quintana
Stubs -
Stubs -
#247
Ryan January, 66 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.52 TR
Ryan January
Stubs -
Stubs -
#248
Chadwick Tromp, 66 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.42 TR
Chadwick Tromp
Stubs -
Stubs -
#249
Ivan Herrera, 66 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.35 TR
Ivan Herrera
Stubs -
Stubs -
#250
Dominic Miroglio, 65 Live - MLB the Show 23
65.29 TR
Dominic Miroglio
Stubs -
Stubs -

Best Catchers in MLB The Show 23 - Insights

2023 All-Star Adley Rutschman holds the top spot among the best Catchers with an impressive 113.72 True Rating, and also is notable within the top 5 for benefiting significantly from 7 active quirks.

Right behind Adley Rutschman are Kaiju Joe Mauer and 2023 Finest Adley Rutschman, forming a strong top group. Overall, the top 10 MLB Catchers average a 110.10 True Rating.

2023 Finest Sean Murphy the most recent addition to the top 10, released 2 years ago.