MLB The Show 25 Player Ratings in Diamond Dynasty

Complete MLB The Show Database

Hal Newhouser

CORE

|

Captain

99

L/L

SP

C R 16

C L 12

P R 10

P L 6

VIS 16

CLU 10

FLD 68

SPD 43

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Sweeping Curve Sweep Crv

78

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

80

VEL

94

CTL

97

BRK

Slider Slider

87

VEL

90

CTL

91

BRK

2-Seam Fastball 2-SM FB

97

VEL

87

CTL

89

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Sweeping Curve Sweep Crv

78

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

80

VEL

94

CTL

97

BRK

Slider Slider

87

VEL

90

CTL

91

BRK

2-Seam Fastball 2-SM FB

97

VEL

87

CTL

89

BRK

Zack Wheeler

CORE

|

Milestone

99

L/R

SP

506,632

644,999

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 1

CLU 0

FLD 42

SPD 25

506,632

644,999

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

98

VEL

99

CTL

92

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

95

CTL

95

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

93

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

82

VEL

90

CTL

99

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

88

VEL

88

CTL

82

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

98

VEL

99

CTL

92

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

95

CTL

95

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

93

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

82

VEL

90

CTL

99

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

88

VEL

88

CTL

82

BRK

Yoshinobu Yamamoto

CORE

|

2025 Postseason

99

R/R

SP

C R 4

C L 7

P R 2

P L 6

VIS 5

CLU 6

FLD 64

SPD 38

Splitter Split

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

98

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

78

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

97

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

95

CTL

85

BRK

Splitter Split

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

98

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

78

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

97

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

95

CTL

85

BRK

Yoshinobu Yamamoto

CORE

|

2025 Postseason

99

R/R

RP

C R 4

C L 7

P R 2

P L 6

VIS 5

CLU 6

FLD 64

SPD 38

Splitter Split

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

98

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

79

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

96

CTL

85

BRK

Splitter Split

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

98

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

79

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

96

CTL

85

BRK

Yoshinobu Yamamoto

CORE

|

2025 Postseason

99

R/R

SP

C R 4

C L 7

P R 2

P L 6

VIS 5

CLU 6

FLD 64

SPD 38

Splitter Split

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

78

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

93

VEL

92

CTL

96

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

90

CTL

80

BRK

Splitter Split

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

78

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

93

VEL

92

CTL

96

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

90

CTL

80

BRK

Whitey Ford

CORE

|

Captain

99

L/L

SP

C R 14

C L 19

P R 13

P L 8

VIS 11

CLU 8

FLD 73

SPD 30

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

93

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Slider Slider

82

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

92

VEL

95

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

75

VEL

94

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

76

VEL

88

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

93

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Slider Slider

82

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

92

VEL

95

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

75

VEL

94

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

76

VEL

88

CTL

99

BRK

Tom Seaver

CORE

|

Cornerstone

99

R/R

SP

C R 12

C L 16

P R 5

P L 7

VIS 17

CLU 13

FLD 52

SPD 27

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

99

CTL

96

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

98

CTL

93

BRK

Slider Slider

87

VEL

94

CTL

99

BRK

12-6 Curve 12-6

72

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

76

VEL

87

CTL

83

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

99

CTL

96

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

98

CTL

93

BRK

Slider Slider

87

VEL

94

CTL

99

BRK

12-6 Curve 12-6

72

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

76

VEL

87

CTL

83

BRK

Tarik Skubal

CORE

|

2025 Finest

99

L/L

SP

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 0

CLU 0

FLD 54

SPD 42

Circle Change Circ-Ch

88

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

97

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

96

CTL

88

BRK

Slider Slider

90

VEL

94

CTL

90

BRK

Knuckle-curve Kn-Crv

81

VEL

92

CTL

76

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

88

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

97

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

96

CTL

88

BRK

Slider Slider

90

VEL

94

CTL

90

BRK

Knuckle-curve Kn-Crv

81

VEL

92

CTL

76

BRK

Tanner Bibee

CORE

|

Spotlight

99

R/R

SP

C R 14

C L 12

P R 2

P L 2

VIS 11

CLU 8

FLD 78

SPD 33

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

96

VEL

98

CTL

78

BRK

Cutter Cutter

86

VEL

95

CTL

99

BRK

Sweeper Sweeper

83

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

89

CTL

90

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

81

VEL

85

CTL

85

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

96

VEL

98

CTL

78

BRK

Cutter Cutter

86

VEL

95

CTL

99

BRK

Sweeper Sweeper

83

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

89

CTL

90

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

81

VEL

85

CTL

85

BRK

Steve Carlton

CORE

|

Milestone

99

L/L

SP

5,000

12,000

C R 8

C L 6

P R 6

P L 3

VIS 6

CLU 5

FLD 81

SPD 24

5,000

12,000

Slider Slider

87

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

96

CTL

96

BRK

Curveball Curve

75

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

85

VEL

88

CTL

84

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

84

CTL

76

BRK

Slider Slider

87

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

96

CTL

96

BRK

Curveball Curve

75

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

85

VEL

88

CTL

84

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

84

CTL

76

BRK

Satchel Paige

CORE

|

Hall of Fame

99

R/R

SP

569,250

685,000

C R 10

C L 12

P R 4

P L 9

VIS 7

CLU 10

FLD 66

SPD 45

569,250

685,000

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

80

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

Slider Slider

89

VEL

94

CTL

95

BRK

Screwball Screw

77

VEL

93

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

90

CTL

90

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

80

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

Slider Slider

89

VEL

94

CTL

95

BRK

Screwball Screw

77

VEL

93

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

90

CTL

90

BRK

Roy Halladay

CORE

|

Milestone

99

R/R

SP

C R 12

C L 13

P R 4

P L 11

VIS 13

CLU 9

FLD 62

SPD 49

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

94

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

79

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

84

VEL

92

CTL

93

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

95

VEL

95

CTL

90

BRK

Cutter Cutter

92

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

94

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

79

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Changeup Change

84

VEL

92

CTL

93

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

95

VEL

95

CTL

90

BRK

Rich Gossage

CORE

|

Awards

99

R/R

CP

C R 4

C L 9

P R 3

P L 6

VIS 8

CLU 6

FLD 38

SPD 18

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Slurve Slurve

88

VEL

86

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

82

CTL

85

BRK

Changeup Change

86

VEL

70

CTL

74

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Slurve Slurve

88

VEL

86

CTL

99

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

82

CTL

85

BRK

Changeup Change

86

VEL

70

CTL

74

BRK

Ranger Suárez

CORE

|

2025 Finest

99

L/L

SP

260,000

364,999

C R 8

C L 7

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 11

CLU 7

FLD 85

SPD 39

260,000

364,999

Sinker Sinker

90

VEL

86

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

74

VEL

75

CTL

75

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

91

VEL

86

CTL

60

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

79

VEL

60

CTL

96

BRK

Cutter Cutter

86

VEL

59

CTL

74

BRK

Sinker Sinker

90

VEL

86

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

74

VEL

75

CTL

75

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

91

VEL

86

CTL

60

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

79

VEL

60

CTL

96

BRK

Cutter Cutter

86

VEL

59

CTL

74

BRK

Randy Johnson

CORE

|

Awards

99

R/L

SP

460,000

600,000

C R 14

C L 16

P R 6

P L 11

VIS 16

CLU 11

FLD 57

SPD 38

460,000

600,000

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

88

CTL

99

BRK

Slider Slider

90

VEL

85

CTL

99

BRK

Splitter Split

88

VEL

82

CTL

90

BRK

Slurve Slurve

81

VEL

78

CTL

88

BRK

2-Seam Fastball 2-SM FB

97

VEL

76

CTL

74

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

88

CTL

99

BRK

Slider Slider

90

VEL

85

CTL

99

BRK

Splitter Split

88

VEL

82

CTL

90

BRK

Slurve Slurve

81

VEL

78

CTL

88

BRK

2-Seam Fastball 2-SM FB

97

VEL

76

CTL

74

BRK

Pedro Martinez

CORE

|

Awards

99

R/R

SP

5,025

24,000

C R 12

C L 15

P R 8

P L 11

VIS 12

CLU 11

FLD 67

SPD 37

5,025

24,000

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

82

VEL

97

CTL

99

BRK

Slurve Slurve

81

VEL

95

CTL

95

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

93

CTL

90

BRK

Cutter Cutter

90

VEL

90

CTL

92

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

82

VEL

97

CTL

99

BRK

Slurve Slurve

81

VEL

95

CTL

95

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

93

CTL

90

BRK

Cutter Cutter

90

VEL

90

CTL

92

BRK

Nolan Ryan

CORE

|

Cornerstone

99

R/R

SP

C R 12

C L 16

P R 8

P L 11

VIS 18

CLU 11

FLD 56

SPD 27

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

12-6 Curve 12-6

83

VEL

88

CTL

99

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

79

VEL

80

CTL

95

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

78

CTL

88

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

99

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

12-6 Curve 12-6

83

VEL

88

CTL

99

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

79

VEL

80

CTL

95

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

78

CTL

88

BRK

Nathan Eovaldi

CORE

|

2025 Finest

99

R/R

SP

152,000

205,000

C R 0

C L 0

P R 0

P L 0

VIS 0

CLU 0

FLD 47

SPD 17

152,000

205,000

Splitter Split

88

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

95

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

91

VEL

99

CTL

98

BRK

Curveball Curve

76

VEL

98

CTL

79

BRK

Sinker Sinker

94

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

Splitter Split

88

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

95

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

91

VEL

99

CTL

98

BRK

Curveball Curve

76

VEL

98

CTL

79

BRK

Sinker Sinker

94

VEL

96

CTL

99

BRK

Mike Mussina

CORE

|

Milestone

99

L/R

SP

5,000

20,000

C R 14

C L 10

P R 6

P L 2

VIS 9

CLU 13

FLD 94

SPD 38

5,000

20,000

Sinker Sinker

94

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

95

VEL

99

CTL

97

BRK

Cutter Cutter

88

VEL

93

CTL

85

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

83

VEL

86

CTL

80

BRK

Slider Slider

82

VEL

80

CTL

75

BRK

Sinker Sinker

94

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

95

VEL

99

CTL

97

BRK

Cutter Cutter

88

VEL

93

CTL

85

BRK

Circle Change Circ-Ch

83

VEL

86

CTL

80

BRK

Slider Slider

82

VEL

80

CTL

75

BRK

Max Fried

CORE

|

2025 Finest

99

L/L

SP

245,555

368,777

C R 42

C L 49

P R 15

P L 18

VIS 40

CLU 44

FLD 90

SPD 35

245,555

368,777

Cutter Cutter

95

VEL

99

CTL

83

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

75

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

96

CTL

80

BRK

Sweeper Sweeper

82

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK

Cutter Cutter

95

VEL

99

CTL

83

BRK

Sinker Sinker

95

VEL

99

CTL

99

BRK

Curveball Curve

75

VEL

98

CTL

99

BRK

4-Seam Fastball 4-SM FB

97

VEL

96

CTL

80

BRK

Sweeper Sweeper

82

VEL

92

CTL

99

BRK