MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Captains

Choosing the right MLB The Show captains can significantly impact your gameplay experience, offering unique advantages that align with different playstyles. Each captain brings their own set of abilities to the diamond, allowing players to customize their strategy based on their preferred approach to the game. Whether you're focusing on power hitting, speed on the basepaths, or defensive prowess, there's a captain option designed to enhance your specific strengths and mitigate potential weaknesses.

Captain Tiers, Requirements & Attribute Boosts

The diverse range of captain boosts provides players with strategic depth that elevates MLB The Show 25 beyond a simple baseball simulation. These boosts can affect various aspects of gameplay, from increasing batting contact and power to enhancing pitching accuracy and velocity. As the season progresses and new captains are released, the meta of the game continues to evolve, keeping the experience fresh and encouraging players to experiment with different lineup configurations and strategies.

  • Click a captain to see all eligible players
Select Team
Name
BoostReqTier
Date Added
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Pitch Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Pitch Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 8
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 12
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 8
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 13
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 20
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 8
Contact Right: 13
Contact Left: 13
Clutch: 13
H/9: 13
Contact Right: 20
Contact Left: 20
Clutch: 20
H/9: 20
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
H/9: 5
Pitch Clutch: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
H/9: 13
Pitch Clutch: 13
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
H/9: 20
Pitch Clutch: 20
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 8
Contact Right: 13
Contact Left: 13
Clutch: 13
H/9: 13
Contact Right: 20
Contact Left: 20
Clutch: 20
H/9: 20
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 8
Contact Right: 13
Contact Left: 13
Clutch: 13
H/9: 13
Contact Right: 20
Contact Left: 20
Clutch: 20
H/9: 20
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
H/9: 5
Pitch Clutch: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
H/9: 10
Pitch Clutch: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
H/9: 15
Pitch Clutch: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Pitch Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Pitch Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Pitch Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 12
Contact Left: 12
Clutch: 12
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
H/9: 5
Pitch Clutch: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
H/9: 10
Pitch Clutch: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
H/9: 15
Pitch Clutch: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 10
Contact Left: 10
Clutch: 10
H/9: 10
Contact Right: 15
Contact Left: 15
Clutch: 15
H/9: 15
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25
Contact Right: 3
Contact Left: 3
Clutch: 3
H/9: 3
Contact Right: 5
Contact Left: 5
Clutch: 5
H/9: 5
Contact Right: 8
Contact Left: 8
Clutch: 8
H/9: 8
5
12
18
Tier 1
Tier 2
Tier 3
3-14-25